Reviews for Pink Carnation by Madison

Page 1 of 8
<< Start < Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next > End >>
Kelly (Chapter 4) - Sat 03 Aug 2019

The angst!  It burns!


Kelly (Chapter 3) - Sat 03 Aug 2019

So sad!  My heart hurts for Sesshoumaru.  Someone really should have let Mrs. Higurashi in on the reason why she shouldn't keep calling Inuyasha.


Kelly (Chapter 2) - Sat 03 Aug 2019

Nice chapter!  Loved the confrontation between Sesshoumaru and Inuyasha.  It's too bad Kagome's Mom didn't know any better and called Inuyasha.  I am alnost afraid of what's coming up.  With that head injury, I am wondering if Kagome will have forgotten the last year and think she and Inuyasha are still together.  I am wondering how bad her legs are injured, too.  And who was responsible for the accident.  You've got me on the edge of my seat!


Kelly (Chapter 1) - Sat 03 Aug 2019

Wow!  Great start to this story!  You really have me wondering what exactly happened between Inuyasha and Kagome.  And poor Kagome was in some kind of accident?  When she was trying so hard to have a good day.  Inuyasha really is a jerk in this.  So irresponsible.  Can't wait to read more!


candace peaches (Chapter 21) - Tue 15 Sep 2015

good story. i just know they got their happy ending. good plot and the characters were great in their roles.i was looking for a lemon, but i think it would have taken away the storyline. it was simple, sweet, and to the point. i like simple sometimes makes it easier and more real. c'ya'


Elizabeth (Chapter 21) - Thu 29 Jan 2015

I nearly cried so many times while reading this. You HAVE to do a sequel!  Or a epilogue!  I want to see them together, or to see her come back to him!  PLEASE!


Badtzmaru1907 (Chapter 21) - Wed 03 Sep 2014

Great story you should make a sequel, even a short one!


Jfrost (Chapter 21) - Mon 16 Sep 2013

Oh man!!!!  I loved this story right up until the end!!!  holy crap, no getting together!  I'm so bummed out right now.

 

That said, I never, ever read modern day versions of this, and yet this one really captured my attention.  I read it all the way through and enjoyed it.  Not many people seem capable of maintaining those relationships and translating them into a modern way.  Your version of SEsshomaru I feel was spot on.  I loved their relationship.

 

But I seriously wish there was one more chapter. Just one.  


Ankita (Chapter 21) - Mon 02 Sep 2013

I really loved this storyyy brought me such heartache ... started it last night just completed it now.. loved every single one of the chapter ,you are an amazing author thank you for completing this storyy ... a bit unsatisfied with the ending though, my heart just breaks by watching sesshomaru in this state ..please give him the deserving ending ....


hana sora (Chapter 21) - Thu 11 Oct 2012

you should make it sequel, love your storyy. . .please make it ^^


typicalyssa (Chapter 21) - Sun 08 Jul 2012

I feel so bad for Sesshoumaru!!! You made him out to be such a gentleman as Kagome's silent guardian, it's really touching. I absolutely loved the plot! You got me hooked from start to end. I couldn't wait to find out when Kagome would remember Sesshoumaru. Although the ending was abrupt than what I'd usually like, however, I found it beautiful. The pink carnation at the end just ties up the whole story and promises a happy ending that, sadly, could only be played out in my mind. Thanks for this lovely story. =)


Aya (Chapter 1) - Tue 28 Feb 2012

oh my god you can't leave it like that!!!! ;-; are you going to do a prequeal?? PLLLLEEEEASE Tell me you are!! You can't just leave it with them never getting together!!! ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-; ;-;


ladefreakinha (Chapter 21) - Fri 30 Dec 2011

Loved the plot, disliked the ending. Not because they didn't end up with their 'happily ever after' but because it seemed as if you lost interst and rushed it and, just, not right.. ??

By the way, your an amazing writer.


Patricia (Chapter 21) - Sun 17 Apr 2011

Can I just say best read ive had in a long time! i read the whole thing non stop through every break ive had in the last couple days. I loved the plot and overall i really enjoyed it :) i just wish there could have been a little more romance between the two.. maybe in a sequel?? also inuyasha an kikyo kinda fadded off so im not sure what happend to them.. as well as sess never got the painting given to him like the first chapter sugjested, so i kinda thought that would have been adressed more, anyway not really criticing you just trying to pursade you more into a sequal! lol


SashaMarie (Chapter 21) - Thu 14 Apr 2011

Thanks for a awesome story. I hope there is a sequel. I cant wait if there is. I will be very excited. I loved this story. It made me cry a lot, but I still loved it. So thanks.


Sesshoumaru'sPriestess (Chapter 21) - Thu 14 Apr 2011

Omg ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh sequel?


AmoraLynn (Chapter 21) - Wed 13 Apr 2011

That is absolutly heart breaking, I've been sitting here on the couch trying not to cry so my roommate won't think I'm completely weird. It is a beautiful ending and leaves me wanting to know how things turn out for her. I hope you might do an epilouge someday. :)


Nilee1 (Chapter 21) - Wed 13 Apr 2011

I await the sequel, so I won't be angry that you ended it this way;-)


Carla! (Chapter 21) - Wed 13 Apr 2011

You are going to write a sequel, right!? 

>.<

I mean... he will wait for her... so we MUST know what happens when she finally decides to come back to him! 

PLEASE!!! T0T


vampwinter (Chapter 21) - Wed 13 Apr 2011

that was such a beautifully written story  ....  but I have to say I found the ending sad  .... I know she needed to go away and be by herself for a while  .....  but poor Sesshy  :(  hopefully you will write a sequel????


Page 1 of 8
<< Start < Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next > End >>

INUYASHA © Rumiko Takahashi/Shogakukan • Yomiuri TV • Sunrise 2000
No money is being made from the creation or viewing of content on this site, which is strictly for personal, non-commercial use, in accordance with the copyright.